|
|
Post by Creative Sushi on Dec 3, 2015 16:49:05 GMT
|
|
|
|
Post by Scruffy on Dec 3, 2015 18:26:10 GMT
- I like the color scheme, but I think the background image is a bit too noticably low-res. Though I have no suggestions for a different background image; that one's very good at representing Pikmin/Pikipedia.
- The icons. Most of them are really good. I'm a big fan of the Sunseed Berry vs. Golden Sunseed, it directs your eye well. However they aren't very consistent, and I know that's a problem with Pikmin objects but some sprites just don't seem to fit. The green soft shapes of the forum background don't mix well with the hard shapes of KopPad style elements like the Profiles or the "Options" button. Also, the text for the "Like" and "Options" buttons is too small to be attractive, even though it is good to name what they are. Perhaps buttons like that should just be a different style than KopPad, or the whole forum should be like the KopPad (I prefer the former option).
- The forum layout is fine with me. I'll admit it's a little confusing at times to see a name and know whether that person started the thread or most recently posted in the thread, but that's probably just because I'm new to forums.
- Like I said above, the Profiles should be a different theme than KopPad colors, as they are not consistent with the general style of the forum. Not that consistency in art is a law, but it's approached very carefully in Pikmin, and with the profiles it just seems like one style flatly stuck on top of another. If I could offer a suggestion, the menu elements of Pikmin games usually are inspired by bubbles. Not soap bubbles, but transparent shapes. It might fit the general form of the forum more.
|
|
VIDEO GAMES *kicks chair* |
Post by GoldenTriforce on Dec 4, 2015 0:57:09 GMT
*I derped up I thought yes was do you like the forums. I meant maybe*
1. Yes. it is a bit convoluted sometimes but it is good.
2.Icons are good I don't see an issue with them/
3. Yes
4. I do wish there was more you could do with the profiles like have a message wall or even some Pikmin related thing (like maybe a place to answer your favorite Pikmin games or high scores or stuff like that as some of the profile questions). IF those are possible of course, freeforums may not allow it. The overall design is good.
|
|
|
|
Post by The Shearsquid on Dec 4, 2015 1:23:38 GMT
1. It's fine.
2. The Sunseed Berry and Golden Sunseed Berry work fine, but I do miss the very beginning having Cupid's Grenades and Golden Cupid's Grenades.
3. The layout works swell.
4. There doesn't seem to be any purpose for following someone. A list of their activities as of late would give it more meaning.
|
|
|
|
Post by Jimble on Dec 4, 2015 16:49:38 GMT
1. Looks fine how it is, suits Pikmin.
2. The icons are pretty cool right now, maybe you could occasionally change them for events to other fruits/treasures/ship parts (like a Christmas styled set of icons for December), either way, it's fine how it is now.
3. The layout is also fine.
4. The profiles are great, at first I got kind of confused but I think I've got it all figured out now (I've never been good with forums so it's probably just me).
|
|
<insert status thingy here> |
Post by PikFan23 on Dec 6, 2015 7:07:05 GMT
1. Per Scruffy that the background image is too low quality. Otherwise, I don't mind the color scheme.
2. Get a better icon for new threads; an empty ellipse(?) just doesn't sit well with me. Otherwise, icons are fine.
3. The layout's alright, though I think that the profiles on the left are a bit too tall. If we could shrink them, then there wouldn't be so much white space.
4. Profiles seem okay, I don't really pay attention to them much.
|
|
|
|
Post by Creative Sushi on Dec 18, 2015 8:38:47 GMT
Thank you for all the Feedback guys. Gonna go ahead and lock this thread. I've added a To-do section to the forum changelog here. For additional feedback please create a thread here. |
|
